Okay, it's been a couple of weeks. So, here is the promised update on my impressions of the Caitlin2 series strap made by Gunny.
Some Details
This one is 3-ply (or 6mm) with a sewn in GPF buckle. I also had it made a little long, and asked him to cut the tail long and pointy. Peter didn't have any brushed GPFs in stock at the time, but he was fine with brushing it himself before sewing it in, so long as I promised not to complain about the results being unprofessional. And it looks fine as far as I'm concerned; I'm satisfied. The thickness is awesome. As I must have said a dozen times by now above, this strap is very soft and comfortable. I've noticed two small issues that some might consider an imperfection. First, the distance from lug to "closed stitching" threads on the two pieces is not consistent. At first, my OCD alarm went off. But, I soon decided that this was intentional. I'm writing it off to artistic license, and it is probably genius. Because 'my view' versus 'the world's view' on the tail -vs- noon side could be argued to require/prefer slightly different designs. The other issue is the width of the strap. Luminor lug widths are 24mm. This strap is closer to 23mm. Again, there is actually an asthetic appeal to the marginally thinner strap when one is gazing at the wrist. However, if you put an OCD eye on the actual lugs themselves, that tiny gap talks to you like Poe's Tell-Tale Heart. I'm more inclined to think this was oversight than intentional. Or possibly even intentional only in the interest of optimizing the number of straps coming out of some piece of leather. I'm spreading lies and rumors at this point however.
All in all, the bottom line is that this strap is exceptional. The big picture, all things considered, holistic, "did he pull it off?" question can be answered without hesitation. This is easily my current new favorite non-OEM strap. Five thumbs Gunny. You're doing something meaningful with your life. Keep bringing it! I personally plan to continue supporting this artist.
* But now, something else calls ...