I've heard Run-Flats are bad in Rain.....
- rockmastermike
- Feedback Virtuoso
- Posts: 20579
- Joined: Tue May 18, 2010 5:13 pm
- Name: WDE
I've heard Run-Flats are bad in Rain.....
poor traction in rain, snow, expensive to replace and harsh ride are the cons to having these on your ride....any truth to this?
Re: I've heard Run-Flats are bad in Rain.....
Expensive to replace for certain. I’ve not driven enough on them to really give you an opinion on harshness or handling, but I’ve heard the sticker shock from people who needed to replace them.
Re: I've heard Run-Flats are bad in Rain.....
Have them on my BMW wagon. I don’t see any traction difference vs non run flat... I mean the tread and rubber compound shouldn’t be any different. I suppose maybe at the track where stiffer sidewalls might allow less traction to be put down through high speed cornering. Main difference is stiffer sidewalls. Ride can be harsh if you have them with super low profile tires.
Many BMW drivers ditch them right away, but then you are left without a safety net during a flat and are forced to call a tow truck as there is no spare. Here in Indiana pothole season eats tires so I have 17” wheel with runflats with a decent sidewall profile and the ride is fine.
As far as cost, seemed like when I replaced them they were maybe $20 per tire more than the Pirelli non run flats, but you have less options. For me it is a worthy trade off as I would rather not be late for a meeting stranded on an interstate somewhere.
Many BMW drivers ditch them right away, but then you are left without a safety net during a flat and are forced to call a tow truck as there is no spare. Here in Indiana pothole season eats tires so I have 17” wheel with runflats with a decent sidewall profile and the ride is fine.
As far as cost, seemed like when I replaced them they were maybe $20 per tire more than the Pirelli non run flats, but you have less options. For me it is a worthy trade off as I would rather not be late for a meeting stranded on an interstate somewhere.
- JP Chestnut
- Posts: 17821
- Joined: Mon May 27, 2013 10:40 am
- Name: Jacob
- Location: Ithaca, NY USA
Re: I've heard Run-Flats are bad in Rain.....
They’re heavy too.
Re: I've heard Run-Flats are bad in Rain.....
Yeah, I just looked up the non flat Pirelli P7 tires on my car for apples to apples and they are 23 lbs vs 27 lbs on the run flat. A spare tire, wheel and jack will weigh 40+ lbs so overall run flats allow manufacturers to keep weight down and save space.... but the heavier tires are unsprung weight which impacts handling.
- jswing
- Founder, TDWC MM300 Fan Club
- Posts: 8356
- Joined: Sat Mar 12, 2011 8:54 am
- Name: Jeff
- Location: NJ
Re: I've heard Run-Flats are bad in Rain.....
I just got a BMW 230ix with my first set of run flats, and I honestly haven't noticed any difference from non run-flats. My only options at order were run flats or performance tires, and I really didn't want performance tires. Like Nick said, mine have a decent sidewall (50s) so that helps absorb harshness. I don't think I've driven it in snow yet, but it's been perfectly fine in rain. It's all wheel drive and has all sorts of driver assist junk which helps with traction.
Re: I've heard Run-Flats are bad in Rain.....
Yes, replaced mine on my X5 a couple years ago, haven't looked back. Huge improvement in ride, and improved traction.rockmastermike wrote: ↑Sat Mar 20, 2021 4:35 ampoor traction in rain, snow, expensive to replace and harsh ride are the cons to having these on your ride....any truth to this?
They really aren't worth it, even if you get a flat they are only good for 20 miles at low speeds. Much rather get a tow truck (or buy a spare tire kit).
Re: I've heard Run-Flats are bad in Rain.....
Run flats of mid-2000’s sucked, but current ones are significantly improved. I wouldn’t hesitate to run them.
Re: I've heard Run-Flats are bad in Rain.....
My Pirelli’s are rated for 50mph for 50 miles when flat, or similar to a spare. That is good enough to get me to my meeting on time, or to a tire shop.
Re: I've heard Run-Flats are bad in Rain.....
Depends what you want out of the tires. My first 2007 RFT were terrible. Newer ones are much better but they’re nowhere near as good as something like P4S. For regular driving they’re almost as good as regular. BMW runs normal tires on their M models and you can ask the dealer to swap for non-RFT on others
Re: I've heard Run-Flats are bad in Rain.....
Glad you are happy with them. To an earlier point, lower profile tires will always ride harsher (especially run-flats). They are heavier, which can affect handling, and more expensive (often much more if you are running a larger diameter/low profile tire).
If you go on any of the BMW forums/Facebook groups you will find many, many have ditched them and are quite happy to be rid of them.
I personally haven't had a catastrophic flat in at least 10 years. PLENTY of slow leaks from nails, etc. that resulted in a new tire or a patch, but nothing that has left me stranded by the side of the road. Because of that I haven't bothered to purchase a spare, jack, etc.
Re: I've heard Run-Flats are bad in Rain.....
I’ve been driving on them for ten years- I think they handle fine, ride can be rough at times; they don’t wear well-
I don’t find them to be too pricey..
Many guys I know put snow tires on here in northeast.
I don’t find them to be too pricey..
Many guys I know put snow tires on here in northeast.
- toxicavenger
- President Tranny
- Posts: 48110
- Joined: Fri Mar 12, 2010 8:25 am
- Name: HeadDIK
- Location: Colorado Springs
Re: I've heard Run-Flats are bad in Rain.....
if my car came with them I would keep them until they wore out. after that i personally would not buy them.
Website: http://smallwhitestubbies.com/
Re: I've heard Run-Flats are bad in Rain.....
They do what they are designed to do well but not much else. Most people probably won’t notice their deficiencies in other areas and advertising run flats help sell cars and tires. Once you match a better tire and characteristics to your vehicle you will realize how bad they are.
Regards
Barry
Barry
- rockmastermike
- Feedback Virtuoso
- Posts: 20579
- Joined: Tue May 18, 2010 5:13 pm
- Name: WDE
Re: I've heard Run-Flats are bad in Rain.....
Thanks, everyone....I'll plug all of this into the bat computer later this afternoon
Re: I've heard Run-Flats are bad in Rain.....
Avoid is my recommendation. Get real tires.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 138 guests