I like them both, but...

[JDC222]

...which one would you choose? I have some "pocket money" and these are both for sale locally. Both have full kit and are within a few hundred $ of each other.

Ti Seamaster


Steel Black Bay

[River Rat]

The Tudor a no brainer you should not have to ask.

[tmw]

Omega, by far.

As much as that is a good BB, the larger case with the BB (vs) the 58 - is just not as clean and proportioned.

The omega is a classic - and hard to find. The original 1120 movements will run forever, and are omega's original workhorse.

[demer03]

Omega. The case sits so much better.

[Batt14]

The Omega. I too like the way it sits on the wrist.

[unsub073]

Typically like Tudors, but between those two, I would go with the Omega.

[sierra11b]

Omega. The case sits so much better.

This

[Zidane]

2231 for me. Awesome watch. Wish I hadn’t sold mine.

[JP Chestnut]

I don’t like watches that use a soft grade of TI. They don’t hold up at all. I also don’t like that BB. I’d skip both and go with a 2254.

[hoppyjr]

You should get the Tudor and hook me up with the Omega.

[Joeprez]

I would take the Omega because it will fit me better on natos, which is how I would wear that Seamaster. I had the original blue Seamaster "Bond" (similar case to that one) and on bracelet it was a tad too thin for my liking. As soon as I tried a PO, I sold it to get a PO.

That Tudor is really, really nice, but it's big for my wrist on natos. If I was to wear it on the bracelet or a rubber strap, I would go for it.

[toxicavenger]

the ti omega wears excellent

[namor]

The Tudor a no brainer you should not have to ask.

+1

[BBK357]

Omega by a Mile and a half.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Mr_Pacman]

The Omega for sure. if you decide to pass on that one and it's in Canada, I would be interested in getting in line to buy it.

[JBZ]

I'd go with the Omega. More comfortable and easier to sell if it doesn't stick. I actually like the design of the BB better, but I've really tried to like that case and I just can't.

But if you can find a 2254 (as was suggested), that's the way I'd go.

[deepcdvr]

I've had them both within the last year and I also would go with the Omega for the following reasons:

- Omega wears like a dream, Tudor not so much. Kind of top heavy and weirdly 'big', imo
- Tudor in house movement: I've had issues on both watches I've owned with that movement. Admittedly, Tudor fixed both problems, but it was a pain to ship/wait, etc...

Good luck!

[JDC222]

Wow, Omega is killing it!! I do like Ti too...hmmm.

[Bradystraps]

Love that Omega and always have but... that Tudor is special. It is on my short list so I vote that way.

[59yukon01]

Omega no doubt.

[CGSshorty]

Omega by a landslide for me. You never see the titanium versions anymore.

[JDC222]

Omega by a landslide for me. You never see the titanium versions anymore.

Thanks guys, I’ve been leaning that way too...

[AtomicTom]

I actually love that Black Bay Dave.

But I think the Seamaster in titanium mode is a little different, so maybe
would slightly lean in it's direction. It's a tough one though. Wow,
good luck in your decision here !

[Abmw]

Omega feels really light in stainless steel. I imagine in titanium it will wear even better.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[ChuckW]

I confess, I have a weakness for the Peter Blake style SMPs.