Funny that Gerald genta didn't even like watches he says.
And, he only had an hour to design the AP.
The video said he had a day. And he designed the Nautilus in 5 minutes. Either way, ridiculous deadlines that did result in some design oddities - that seem to work somehow.
Re: Very interesting AP vs PP video
Posted: Thu Dec 21, 2017 10:06 am
by apnk
I've never really been a fan of the Nautilus until now, looks great. AP's dials reminds me of waffles.
Those ears are a no-go for me. Whenever I see the watch I can't help but see this:
I'm pretty sure that the Nautilus is another of the million bracelet watches that I can't wear due to a lack of adjust ability in bracelet sizing. Whatever, I'm a Rolex guy. I'm not sure that I could spend $25,000 on a SS watch with crappy adjust ability and high service needs.
Re: Very interesting AP vs PP video
Posted: Thu Dec 21, 2017 11:19 am
by BacoNoir
I love my AP RO. I prefer the harsher more angular lines I’ve the Nautilus - even before I learned the latter was designed for women!
Re: Very interesting AP vs PP video
Posted: Thu Dec 21, 2017 11:28 am
by Torrid
I definitely prefer the AP seeing them side by side.
Re: Very interesting AP vs PP video
Posted: Thu Dec 21, 2017 11:31 am
by Denizen
Of those two, I'd take the Nautilus. But yes, high servicing costs go with the territory. And it's a definite drag.
Personally, both are in a huge bubble right now, and I don't get the hero-worship. 6+ months waitlist for the privilege of dropping 25k on a Nautilus that's still using the same movement (non-hacking, mind you) back from when it cost half as much?
This is a fundamentally stupid hobby, but that shit is batshit crazy.
Re: Very interesting AP vs PP video
Posted: Thu Dec 21, 2017 12:50 pm
by 59yukon01
So if either one of these had been marketed under lessor prestigious names would anyone here really like them? I'm not a fan of the looks of either, so just sayin.
So if either one of these had been marketed under lessor prestigious names would anyone here really like them? I'm not a fan of the looks of either, so just sayin.
You mean like this...
or this...
or this...
I think it's one part brand value, ten parts design consistency. None of these have generated the following that AP and PP have, despite huge brand status.
Re: Very interesting AP vs PP video
Posted: Thu Dec 21, 2017 1:28 pm
by BacoNoir
59yukon01 wrote:So if either one of these had been marketed under lessor prestigious names would anyone here really like them? I'm not a fan of the looks of either, so just sayin.
I will say, I didn’t like the AP RO in photos and much preferred the VC Overseas. I went to look at them before making final decision, and the AP RO won me over - the dial and rotor are pieces of art. Being an engineer, I much appreciated the old school mechanical method used t create the tapestry dial.
So if either one of these had been marketed under lessor prestigious names would anyone here really like them? I'm not a fan of the looks of either, so just sayin.